How Cataracts and World War I Shaped Monet's Water Lilies

How Cataracts and World War I Shaped Monet's Water Lilies

In the quiet of his Giverny studio, 72-year-old Claude Monet stood over his palette, reading the fine print on small metal paint tubes. He had to. He could no longer rely on his eyes to tell cobalt blue from deep green. If a tube went into the wrong slot on his wooden palette, an entire canvas would end up ruined.

In 1912, eye specialist Dr. Richard Liebreich confirmed what Monet had feared for years: bilateral nuclear cataracts. The natural lenses in both eyes were hardening into a dense, yellowed haze. The artist who spent five decades chasing daylight was slowly losing his ability to see color.

When people look at the giant impressionism art water lily murals in Paris today, it is easy to view them as a peaceful artistic choice. But their creation was anything but calm. It was a fierce struggle involving smashed canvases, a prime minister's stubborn friendship, a frightening eye operation, and a promise made the day after World War I ended.

When the Garden Turned Muddy Red

Nuclear cataracts do something strange to light. They act like a heavy yellow filter over your eyes, blocking short wavelengths like blue and violet while letting murky reds, oranges, and dirty yellows flood through.

Monet wrote bitter letters to friends, explaining that white lilies looked yellow to him and deep blues looked like brown mud. To keep painting his garden, he forced himself to work by muscle memory and palette slots. Yet when he stepped back to look at his finished work, the results horrified him.

Claude Monet - The Japanese Footbridge (c. 1920-1922)
Claude Monet, The Japanese Footbridge (c. 1920-1922). Painted during his severe cataract period, dominated by fiery reds and dark oranges. Public domain image courtesy of The Museum of Modern Art (MoMA).

Between 1914 and 1922, his delicate garden scenes vanished. In their place came heavy, fiery depictions of his Japanese footbridge, painted in thick, dark rust and deep orange. Furious with his failing sight, Monet flew into rages. He dragged finished canvases into the courtyard, slashed them with studio knives, and stomped them into the dirt.

A Promise for Peace on Armistice Day

One person refused to let Monet quit: Georges Clemenceau. Clemenceau was the Prime Minister of France during the grimmest stretch of World War I, and a close personal friend. He visited Giverny regularly, pushing Monet to focus on a grand, multi-canvas project depicting the lily pond.

On November 12, 1918 (the day after the WWI Armistice was signed), Monet wrote to Clemenceau offering to donate two massive painted panels to France as a monument to peace. That gift eventually expanded into 22 monumental murals, spanning nearly 100 meters of canvas.

Monet wanted to create an uninterrupted sanctuary for tired city dwellers. But as the war ended, his vision got worse. He stubbornly held onto the canvases, refusing to let the French government touch them until he could see clearly enough to finish them properly.

The Eye Surgery and the Blue Shock

Monet avoided eye surgery for years. He had seen impressionist Mary Cassatt undergo a failed cataract procedure that left her unable to paint, and the risk terrified him. By late 1922, however, he was almost completely blind in his right eye.

In January 1923, at age 82, Monet finally agreed to let Dr. Charles Coutela operate on his right eye to remove the ruined lens.

When the bandages came off, Monet suffered a bizarre shock: cyanopsia. Without a lens to block ultraviolet light, his eye was flooded with intense, unnatural blue and violet light. He hated it instantly, complaining that everything looked like a harsh purple glare and that he could no longer judge warm tones.

It took months of adjustment and special Zeiss glasses fitted with blue-blocking lenses before his color vision settled back to normal.

Three Years Locking the Studio Doors

Once he could see properly again, Monet did something remarkable. He locked his studio doors and spent the last three years of his life repainting the 22 peace panels.

Claude Monet - Water Lilies (Ninfee e Nuvole) at Musée de l'Orangerie
Claude Monet, Water Lilies (Clouds) (c. 1920-1926). One of the panoramic panels installed in the oval rooms at the Musée de l'Orangerie in Paris. Public domain image via Wikimedia Commons.

He scraped away the harsh, muddy red paint he had applied during his years of partial blindness. Working late into his eighties, he repainted the water surfaces with cool emerald greens, soft purples, and translucent water blues, building delicate landscape wall art views of floating blossoms and sky reflections.

Monet worked on the peace gift until his death in December 1926. Five months later, in May 1927, the grand installation opened inside two custom oval rooms at the Musée de l'Orangerie in Paris, arranged in a wide horizontal wall art layout under natural skylights.

Those serene, floating botanical art blooms were not painted in easy leisure. They were won through sheer grit by an old artist who read paint tubes by touch, survived eye surgery at 82, and spent his final years bringing blue back to his canvas.

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Best sellers
View all
Latest artworks
View all