In June 1958, Joseph Seagram & Sons offered Mark Rothko $35,000 to paint a series of murals for the ground floor of their new 38-story Manhattan headquarters at 375 Park Avenue. The sum, equivalent to over $370,000 today, was the largest private commission ever extended to an abstract expressionist. The target space was not a museum or a public gallery of framed posters; it was the interior dining room of the Four Seasons, a restaurant designed by architects Ludwig Mies van der Rohe and Philip Johnson to serve as an icon of midcentury architecture wall art and corporate luxury.
Rothko accepted the money immediately. His friends were stunned, assuming the 54-year-old painter had finally surrendered his radical anti-capitalist posture to sell expensive canvas art. They did not realize he had taken the job as an act of hostility.
A Malicious Commission on Bowery
In the summer of 1959, while traveling across the Atlantic aboard the ocean liner SS Constitution, Rothko revealed his underlying motive to journalist John Fischer of Harper’s Magazine. Sitting on the deck, Rothko explained that he had signed the contract with strictly malicious intentions. He told Fischer:
"I hope to paint something that will ruin the appetite of every son of a bitch who ever eats in that room."
To achieve that goal, Rothko abandoned the glowing, feather-edged yellows and radiant oranges that had brought him commercial fame during the early 1950s. He turned instead to a brooding, somber palette of deep crimson and red wall art aesthetics dominated by dark maroon, plum, and black wall art tones. He looked to classical architecture rather than modern decor, specifically citing Michelangelo’s vestibule in the Laurentian Library in Florence, where blind windows and heavy stone walls were engineered to make visitors feel intentionally trapped.
Working in a dim studio on Bowery using custom scaffolding built to mimic the restaurant’s exact architectural proportions, he mixed rabbit-skin glue with powdered dry pigments, whole eggs, dammar resin, and commercial Lithol Red PR 49 to build dark, unvarnished crimson and maroon portals that felt less like conventional abstract wall art and more like suffocating brick barriers.
Over fourteen months of intense isolation, Rothko produced three distinct sets totaling more than thirty mural-scale canvases. He worked under the conviction that the oppressive visual mass of the dark canvases would overwhelm the dining room, forcing wealthy patrons to feel claustrophobic while eating expensive steaks.
The Dinner at the Four Seasons
In late 1959, after returning to New York from his European voyage, Rothko and his wife Mel decided to visit the newly opened Four Seasons for dinner. It was his first time seeing the finished room in person.
The experience shattered his scheme. As he watched well-dressed diners order $35 meals while oblivious to the surrounding architecture, Rothko realized that no amount of dark maroon paint could disturb people who viewed art exclusively as a symbol of status. The room did not feel oppressed by his vision; rather, his vision was swallowed by the ambient chatter of corporate power.
Rothko walked out of the restaurant furious. He called his studio assistant, Dan Rice, and declared:
"Anybody who will eat that kind of food for those kind of prices will never look at a painting of mine."
Without hesitation, Rothko repudiated the agreement. He returned the full $35,000 fee to Joseph Seagram & Sons, ordered the finished canvases rolled up and stored in his studio, and refused to allow a single painting to hang on the restaurant walls.
The Arrival at the Tate
For nearly a decade, the Seagram Murals remained wrapped in darkness on Bowery. Rothko refused numerous purchase offers from private collectors, insisting that the canvases constituted a single, unified environment that could never be broken up or sold as individual luxury commodities.
In November 1968, Tate Gallery Director Norman Reid visited Rothko in New York. Rothko agreed to gift nine of the monumental Seagram canvases to the Tate in London, provided the museum fulfilled a strict condition: the paintings had to be displayed together in a dedicated, dimly lit room with no other artists' work present to disrupt their contemplative weight.
The wooden crates containing the nine murals arrived at the London docks on February 25, 1970. That exact same morning, studio assistant Oliver Steindecker found Mark Rothko dead on his Manhattan studio floor, having taken his own life at age 66.
Today, the murals hang inside the dedicated Rothko Room at Tate Modern. Instead of serving as background noise for a Midtown expense account dinner, the maroon portals sit in quiet dark light, exactly as Rothko intended when he chose integrity over $35,000.
0 comments